Denemo is a lot better than i remember it.
i sing in choir. since i'm a terrible pianist, i cannot really sit in front of a piano and play my line of a song easily. this isn't a big problem for some of the music we sing, either because there's an easily accessible rehearsal track, or because we rehearse as a group frequently enough that i pick it up at practice. however, if it's difficult but not particularly well known, i'm in a position to have to make my own rehearsal track.
Denemo is score editing software for Linux...basically, a front end for Lilypond, a GNU music score engraver. it's useful for writing down compositions, but also invaluable if you need to learn a vocal line. it is supposed to allow you to type in a line with associated directions, and then play it back. you can follow along with the score; it plays what you've typed in accurately, unlike my inept piano fingers.
i remember using it about two years ago to make some rehearsal scores, but it was a clunky mess. the keyboard shortcuts weren't particularly intuitive, the menus were a mess, and i had a terrible time getting any of the graphical windows or mouse shortcuts to work. it was an unpleasant experience...i slogged through because i needed to have something reliable from which to rehearse some solos i was trying out for, but i cursed that program left and right. it was so bad that i went back to taking pieces to the rehearsal pianos at the library and blundering through them there. that's BAD.
tonight, i finally revisited it. i needed something in order to make some rehearsal materials for pieces i'm singing this season, and there was no way i was ever going to be able to stumble through playing all my parts. i wanted to give it one more try, since it had been so long. i was excited to see that it worked significantly better than before. the default keyboard shortcuts were easier to type: numbers for notes, and alt-numbers for the corresponding rests. the menus and mouse shortcuts actually work...i'm not tearing my hair out anymore about how to enter a time signature, key change, a fermata, a repeat sign, or anything else! and, if i want to make keyboard shortcuts that make sense to me for any or all of the edits i commonly make to a score, i can.
it isn't perfect. it took me several tries to get triplets to work correctly; this annoyed me greatly, as there were two pieces i was entering in which my line had a ton of triplets. furthermore, even though counting up from 0 instead of from 1 is correct (and the geekier way to do it), it's annoying to have the keyboard shortcut for a whole note (0) on the right side of my keyboard, and then start at 1, 2, 3 for half note, eighth note, sixteenth note, etc. however, i think that can be rectified by changing my keyboard shortcuts around, something i may do if i end up using this program with some frequency.
finally, i'm even more excited because once i did the work of typing in my line from each of my scores, it was so easy to turn each rehearsal score into an mp3 that i can toss on my iPod and listen to when i'm running around town. i just saved the Denemo file as a MIDI file (from right inside Denemo). since i had timidity (a MIDI player, which will also play MIDI files as .wav files) and LAME (an .mp3 encoder) installed on my machine, i just ran the following two commands on the MIDI file:
$ timidity -Ow file.mid -o file.wav $ lame file.wavand, there it was. an .mp3 of a piano playing my line in the song, far better than i would ever be able to play it.

Comments
Thanks for your interest. Permalink
Submitted by anonymous on Sat, 01/22/2011 - 17:48
Thanks for your interest.
Some time in the future you will be able to directly export .ogg or .mp3 from Denemo. Technically its no problem, its a few lines in our code. But somebody has to do it anyway :)
The problems you have mentioned are known and we constantly work to make those things better. As you noticed, many of them got much better in the last two years.
Feel free to join us on our mailing list or #denemo on irc.freenode.org . I would be happy to hear from you!
Nils
Denemo
About the durations 0,1... I Permalink
Submitted by anonymous on Sun, 01/23/2011 - 06:38
About the durations 0,1... I use the numeric keypad, then they go up in order nicely, and you can get very fast at entering the rhythm of a piece and playing the notes in via a MIDI controller at full speed.
Add new comment